We do have a ton of high rated pitchers. But ALL of them pretty much sucked this year. That's incredible, but when you look at the stats, that is exactly true. Not one pitcher with an ERA under 3.00 and only 3 under 4.00 (Langworthy, Leuthje & Pogue). Our "star" pitcher, Mace & Leftwich were at 5.40 and 6.94. Team ERA was 5.40, over 7.00 vs. the SEC. Horrible!! That doesn't give me any confidence about any of the returning pitchers, although I'm sure a few of them will improve. How much is anybody's guess. But I don't think youth is a valid excuse. We've lost AA picthers numerous times in the past and there were always guys ready to replace them without us missing a beat. Mace, Leftwich & Dyson had the experience and supposed talent to step into the shoes of Singer, Kowar, etc. They simply couldn't do it.
Logan Shore came in as our Friday night starter as a freshman and did a great job for 3 years. Hudson Randall was a solid starter as a freshman and got better each year. Karston Whitson was 8-1, 2.40 ERA as a freshman weekend starter, was doing fine as a sophomore and then got hurt. A.J. Puk and Kirby Snead contributed consistently as freshmen. I could go deeper, on and on, adding guys who relieved as freshmen or threw midweek as freshmen and then moved to weekend starters as sophomore and did great for 2 years, like Faedo. My point is that in most cases pitchers either have it or they don't, especially when it comes to pitching in the SEC.
Mace & Leftwich were really good as freshmen pitching midweek games and they did OK later in the year in relief during SEC games as freshmen. Dyson had that super 3-week stretch in the postseason helping us win the National Title as a freshman. But some pitchers either can't handle the pressure or simply don't have the talent, to be consistent weekend starters in the SEC. Apparently O'Sullivan didn't see that level of talent from the highly-rated group of freshman pitchers he brought in this year to put them in the rotation over Dyson, Mace & Leftwich until the season went in the tank. And when he did finally use them, they weren't successful. Maybe a freshman or two in next year's class will be that good, like Shore, Randall, etc. Maybe a few of this year's group gets better in the off season to step up his game. Kevin O'Sullivan is a great coach, a great recruiter and is excellent at developing pitchers for MLB. He's probably as stunned as anybody about how the entire staffed tanked this year. He will get it fixed and it will be interesting to see which guys emerge as THE guys next season. I know this year's team was hard to watch.