First off Jeff, HS stats don't mean a single thing, they are totally irrelevant.
(wait, where do the recruit star rankings come from, osmosis???)
Football Osmosis -- The spontaneous net movement or diffusion of information molecules through a selectively-permeable membrane from a region of high football genius.... 😉
QB-dt Max Brown Running the ball:
HS Senior - R - 173 for 1,343 yds, 7.8 ypc, 20 TD's, ZERO fumbles.
And while taking a beating while running the ball that much, how did that negatively affect his passing?
P - 167 of 235, 71.1% for 2,750 yds, 16.5 yd/comp, 41 TD's, 4 Ints, QBR 142.6
4,000+ combined yards with 61 TD's to 4 TO's on 408 plays, less than 1 TO per 100 plays.
But just remember, HS stats don't matter for Max, they just matter for the other guys like a 5-star Mertz, 4-star Miller, and 5-star Lagway....
And College stats don't matter either, just the unqualified opinions of all of us biased others....
=======
Entitled Fan's Given:
When you agree wid da co-ach, then he's an unquestionable genius.
When you don't agree, then he's an unqualified idiot....
Coaches get hired and paid for their recruiting, not for the player development.
But in our coaches situation, he can really coach up the QB's, like he did AR-15 and Miller...
And just like he's done with Max since he recruited him,,, errr flipped him to UF....
Isn't 'TALKING SEASON' a complete joy to be involved with? 😁
Brown ran around until he had receivers wide open mostly avoiding big hits on most of those passing plays. Now a QB like Simmons who stands in the pocket a lot hitting nice passing plays is a lot more likely to be the real deal at the next level imo. You just can't be sure how those QBs that play like Brown in high school will translate until you see them live in practice in college - especially when the talent level was pretty low in their high school division.