I am still waiting for all these 3 star phenoms to pay off against the teams with mostly blue chippers starting - Bama, FSU, Michigan etc. - Well we did beat LSU once due to turnovers despite giving up a bunch of yards.
I guess it depends on what you mean by pay off....
But I like this list so far as Gator players, and others may get there eventually.
2017
FS Shawn Davis
RB Adarius Lemons
Ath Kadarius Toney
RB Malik Davis
DT Kyree Campbell
2016
K Eddy Pineiro
MLB David Reese
DE Jachai Polite
RB Lamical Perine
LG Brett Heggi
2015
DE Jabari Zuniga
OLB Kylan Johnson
RT/RG Fred Johnson
OC/OG/OT Tyler Jordan
I didn't bother to list the suspended buttheads, or the few transfers.
Dumbaway would be on that list also, IF he wasn't such a butthead....