ADVERTISEMENT

Fields to tOSU

As much as I want to be a fan and claim that these students should be going to a particular school because of the school itself, we know that's a sham. There should be SOMETHING in place for when they get recruited and sign with a coaching staff, only to see that coaching staff leave in a year or less for a better job. And the kids are left there with the school and the system is built against them as far as transferring. There is NOTHING the NCAA does to inhibit the coaching carousel every year. Right now, how do you think many of those young OSU players feel who went up there to play for THE Urban Meyer. He took talent from Florida and all over the country. Those kids didn't all grow up wishing to be Buckeyes, they traveled up there to play for a coaching icon. Now that he's retired, how fair is it for all the newly minted sophomores or juniors on that team to be stuck with whoever they have as head coach and the system will not allow them to transfer out or such without demonstrating hardship?
Hard to argue with that...I agree...not sure that their is going to be a perfect system...there will be pros and cons.
 
As much as I want to be a fan and claim that these students should be going to a particular school because of the school itself, we know that's a sham. There should be SOMETHING in place for when they get recruited and sign with a coaching staff, only to see that coaching staff leave in a year or less for a better job. And the kids are left there with the school and the system is built against them as far as transferring. There is NOTHING the NCAA does to inhibit the coaching carousel every year. Right now, how do you think many of those young OSU players feel who went up there to play for THE Urban Meyer. He took talent from Florida and all over the country. Those kids didn't all grow up wishing to be Buckeyes, they traveled up there to play for a coaching icon. Now that he's retired, how fair is it for all the newly minted sophomores or juniors on that team to be stuck with whoever they have as head coach and the system will not allow them to transfer out or such without demonstrating hardship?

Or Temple, where Manny Diaz was for early signing day then bolted for Miami???
 
He knew Georgia already had a 5 Star in Fromm who was just one class ahead of him. If his goal was to play right away there were options like Florida that could have given him that path.

I don't blame him one bit for looking out for his best interests. Millions of dollars are at stake, I question the decision and failure to address his own folly in not looking ahead.
And Eason two classes above. Plus the fact that those two were more pocket passers and he’s more of a DT, it really was a strange decision on his part. Maybe he really liked a girl who went there or something? Guys have done stuff for stupider reasons
 
  • Like
Reactions: PlutoDroid
He’s not leaving because he couldn’t beat out Fromm. Fromm was there when he committed and it’s widely known by people on the team he’s the far superior talent. He just needed to get caught up on the playbook and playing at this level and it was only a matter of time until that happened. UGA sold him on being the guy because if you’ll recall Fromm barely did anything more than hand the ball off until the last two games last year. They also sold him on developing him as a pure QB in a prostyle system but then would only use him as a glorified fullback in games. That’s what the issue was, he felt he wasn’t being developed as a true QB and was not given and opportunity to actually function as a QB in games. If he was worried about competition he wouldn’t have gone there in the first place. Straight from people close to him.
Evidently you didn't watch Fromm last year. We don't beat ND in South Bend without Fromm. He also had a good ypa last year on top of a top 10 ypa this year. If Fields could beat out Fromm, he would still be in Athens. He probably should have put more time into learning the offense. On top of that, Fields has only started 15 high school games. Fromm started 13 his freshman year at UGA. I don't know how Fields thought he could beat out Jake his freshman year with only limited starts hisself during high school.
 
No one is scared of the UGA passing game. It’s why Texas sold out to shut your run game down and Fromm threw 35 passes barely getting over 200 yards in the air. LSU forced him to win the game and he couldn’t. Notre Dame isn’t exactly a team to use as the barometer.
 
It’s also why the #1 WR recruit from Georgia decommitted from UGA and signed with Oklahoma. Fromm is talented but your system is archaic.
 
He knew Georgia already had a 5 Star in Fromm who was just one class ahead of him. If his goal was to play right away there were options like Florida that could have given him that path.

I don't blame him one bit for looking out for his best interests. Millions of dollars are at stake, I question the decision and failure to address his own folly in not looking ahead.

A redshirt is sometimes good, and he needed one more than likely. Almost everyone is so impatient these days!! Heck college is the best time of your life. I stayed five years, well maybe not on purpose.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PlutoDroid
Again, it seems to be that He believed that Kirby was going to change to a more DT QB offense and obviously Fields got the feeling that that wasn't going to happen.

Has less to do with not being able to beat out Fromm.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Michi_Gator
A redshirt is sometimes good, and he needed one more than likely. Almost everyone is so impatient these days!! Heck college is the best time of your life. I stayed five years, well maybe not on purpose.

You probably didn’t have 10+ mill waiting for you when you graduated.
 
Evidently you didn't watch Fromm last year. We don't beat ND in South Bend without Fromm. He also had a good ypa last year on top of a top 10 ypa this year. If Fields could beat out Fromm, he would still be in Athens. He probably should have put more time into learning the offense. On top of that, Fields has only started 15 high school games. Fromm started 13 his freshman year at UGA. I don't know how Fields thought he could beat out Jake his freshman year with only limited starts hisself during high school.

I think any kid worth his salt believes he’s the better player and can beat whoever is there. I think the thing that seemed weird was that he didn’t seem to be a fit for the system. Maybe he was? He’s a very talented kid so who knows.
 
Evidently you didn't watch Fromm last year. We don't beat ND in South Bend without Fromm. He also had a good ypa last year on top of a top 10 ypa this year. If Fields could beat out Fromm, he would still be in Athens. He probably should have put more time into learning the offense. On top of that, Fields has only started 15 high school games. Fromm started 13 his freshman year at UGA. I don't know how Fields thought he could beat out Jake his freshman year with only limited starts hisself during high school.

What? The ND game where he threw for 140 yards and 1 TD? Hope that wasn’t a serious post. Fromm was asked to do very little until the playoffs. That’s not even debatable. Not only was it evident watching the games, it’s supported by stats too.
 
Again, it seems to be that He believed that Kirby was going to change to a more DT QB offense and obviously Fields got the feeling that that wasn't going to happen.

Has less to do with not being able to beat out Fromm.

Let’s be fair, though... Fromm is pretty good. When he’s on he can sit back and pick you apart. I don’t know if that’s Fields’ game
 
As much as I want to be a fan and claim that these students should be going to a particular school because of the school itself, we know that's a sham. There should be SOMETHING in place for when they get recruited and sign with a coaching staff, only to see that coaching staff leave in a year or less for a better job. And the kids are left there with the school and the system is built against them as far as transferring. There is NOTHING the NCAA does to inhibit the coaching carousel every year. Right now, how do you think many of those young OSU players feel who went up there to play for THE Urban Meyer. He took talent from Florida and all over the country. Those kids didn't all grow up wishing to be Buckeyes, they traveled up there to play for a coaching icon. Now that he's retired, how fair is it for all the newly minted sophomores or juniors on that team to be stuck with whoever they have as head coach and the system will not allow them to transfer out or such without demonstrating hardship?

These are STUDENTS in SCHOOL. If they were just athletes, that would be one thing, but they are not.

NFL players don't get to move because a coach leaves. Pretty sure High Schoolers don't get additional transfer ability if a coach leaves. Why should college be special?

Besides, they CAN leave, they just have to sit out a year.
 
What? The ND game where he threw for 140 yards and 1 TD? Hope that wasn’t a serious post. Fromm was asked to do very little until the playoffs. That’s not even debatable. Not only was it evident watching the games, it’s supported by stats too.

He handed off like a champion against ND.
 
These are STUDENTS in SCHOOL. If they were just athletes, that would be one thing, but they are not.

NFL players don't get to move because a coach leaves. Pretty sure High Schoolers don't get additional transfer ability if a coach leaves. Why should college be special?

Besides, they CAN leave, they just have to sit out a year.

Yea but if we’re keeping up the charade of them being students first then the rule makes even less sense. Regular students can transfer anywhere they please as long as their grades are in order. If you want to go to a different school every year until you graduate then you can do just that as long as you get accepted.
 
  • Like
Reactions: seffnergator
He handed off like a champion against ND.
He made several big time passes in South Bend including one for a touchdown. It was also his first college start (and 2nd game) as a true freshman. I think he became the second true freshman qb to ever win a game against Notre Dame in South Bend... pretty impressive. He threw it 29 times that night.
 
Last edited:
He made several big time passes in South Bend including one for a touchdown. It was also his first college start (and 2nd game) as a true freshman. I think he became the second true freshman qb to ever win a game against Notre Dame in South Bend... pretty impressive. He threw it 29 times that night.

Ok, fine. I'm wrong. He handed off like crap against ND.
 
  • Like
Reactions: GADAWGinIraq
He is trying to claim a hardship or fear of safety because a racial slur was used against him by a former Georgia teammate. Said teammate has since been released and stripped of his scholarship. Interesting to see the precedent this ruling will set.
He was a baseball player that was drunk and in the student section.
 
  • Like
Reactions: GADAWGinIraq
These are STUDENTS in SCHOOL. If they were just athletes, that would be one thing, but they are not.

NFL players don't get to move because a coach leaves. Pretty sure High Schoolers don't get additional transfer ability if a coach leaves. Why should college be special?

Besides, they CAN leave, they just have to sit out a year.
I actually transferred bc a school dropped my major. I didn’t have to sit out a year. And yes, they’re students but let’s not pretend they’re just like everyone else. They are at a school for a shot at a pro career and the coaches are a big reason why. If you want to play for a particular system and that option is lost for something that is not your fault, it just seems fair to be able to, if nothing else, followbthe coach you sighed with
 
I actually transferred bc a school dropped my major. I didn’t have to sit out a year. And yes, they’re students but let’s not pretend they’re just like everyone else. They are at a school for a shot at a pro career and the coaches are a big reason why. If you want to play for a particular system and that option is lost for something that is not your fault, it just seems fair to be able to, if nothing else, followbthe coach you sighed with

That attitude is fine, but that would mean we need to separate the schools from the teams and make them local semi-pro teams. Because as long as you are a student athlete, you are a student athlete, not an athlete.

You actually strengthen my point, because you were allowed to transfer for an academic reason.
 
That attitude is fine, but that would mean we need to separate the schools from the teams and make them local semi-pro teams. Because as long as you are a student athlete, you are a student athlete, not an athlete.

You actually strengthen my point, because you were allowed to transfer for an academic reason.

What is your point again? Because, as Ooz pointed out, students can transfer without restriction.
 
Did I miss a rule change? I thought you had to sit at least one year outside of a program going on probation and such???

Anyone know the current rules? Thanks.


He is trying to claim a hardship or fear of safety because a racial slur was used against him by a former Georgia teammate. Said teammate has since been released and stripped of his scholarship. Interesting to see the precedent this ruling will set.
Again, incorrect info. Not a teammate
 
What is your point again? Because, as Ooz pointed out, students can transfer without restriction.
Unless you are a grad student transfer or going from an FBS school to FCS or lower, a player MUST sit out a year, though they are now allowed to transfer any time they want and the university can't stop them. They can apply for an exemption, like Van Jefferson & Shea Patterson did, but the 1 year sit out rule is still in place. https://www.cbssports.com/college-f...g-a-potential-consequence-for-undergraduates/
https://www.usatoday.com/story/spor...uestions-answers-pending-transfer/2348878002/
 
Racism is everywhere and it's not just one-sided. There are racists from every color and creed. I honestly don't believe there are as many as some would like us to believe, but it exists. The problem is that the media just portrays it as a "white" problem.
 
  • Like
Reactions: GwinnettDawg
It’s also why the #1 WR recruit from Georgia decommitted from UGA and signed with Oklahoma. Fromm is talented but your system is archaic.
Well archaic just moved to Tennessee so that's an upgrade from what UcheaT HAS been running.
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT