I was comparing their success as head coaches at UF, not their offenses. As ghost repeatedly pointed out last year, Mac's 2015 is no different than Chump's 2012, in fact the way we ended it was probably less impressive.
Mac, Nuss, Muschamp all have the same stoneage offensive philosophy and Mac will not have the OL or defense to play that way while he is here and be successful doing so.
My only point was I can see a scenario where he does not get his 4th year. One, we have been mediocre too long, two, he isn't the "offense" that Folly promised, three, he is an average recruiter. I mean if we were to lose to UGa and F$U somehow, he would be the first coach in how long to lose to all 3 in one season? Pre-Spurrier? Amd we are going to open next season with an asskicking by Michigan, so how exactly does anyone see him surviving?
I just don't know why it is so hard for people to see what we have. There is no innovation on offense, the recruiting is mediocre, we have not taken steps to improve the OL, we take carries away from Scarlett and Perine to eatch Thompson run into the line and fail everytime. This just isn't the answer to dig us out of this hole, and it never was.