ADVERTISEMENT

Catholicism vs. Protestantism.

I don’t have a horse in this race, but I’ve long felt that the claims that the Roman Catholic church is the one, true, apostolic church loses some steam when you consider that it was the Western church that excommunicated the Eastern church, effectively starting the great schism. I guess catholics would argue that it doesn’t matter due to papal primacy.
We knew they weren’t up to the task of stopping the Muslim invasion that led to the overthrow of Constantinople. We were able to stop them at the Siege of Malta.
 
Quite possible. Admiral Byrd certainly took quite the military force for his “expedition” post WW2 to find out that the Germans had been up to down there.

Totally random, but my uncle was a part of Operation Deep Freeze in Antarctica. Maybe they met. He's dead now, so I can't ask him about it.

Edit: It looks like Byrd died in the 1950s. I think my uncle was on the 1960 expedition, so probably didn't meet.
 
We knew they weren’t up to the task of stopping the Muslim invasion that led to the overthrow of Constantinople. We were able to stop them at the Siege of Malta.

And the Battle of Tours.

But, let's be fair, it's easier to not be conquered by Muslims when you have the Byzantine empire serving as a buffer state in the east and the Mediterranean to the south.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BSC911
And the Battle of Tours.

But, let's be fair, it's easier to not be conquered by Muslims when you have the Byzantine empire serving as a buffer state in the east and the Mediterranean to the south.
Tell that to the Sicilians amigo. The Moorish DNA still has a stranglehold on their appearance.
 
But I guess all they had was the Med to the south as defense. Don’t sell the Moors short. It took Spain half a millennia practically to finally root them out of Spain. And even that was really only possible by the marriage of Ferdinand of Aragon to Isabella of Castile. It was only by unifying the 2 smaller kingdoms of Spain into the country that we mostly recognize today that they had the force to expel the Moors.
 
Different earth ages?

I guess you could call it that. I believe there was high civilization before the flood. I think science definitely proves that a series of catastrophes befell our planet about 12,500 years ago. I can’t definitively say something like Atlantis or Lemuria existed but I do think civilization was advanced perhaps even in some ways beyond what we are today.
I think the great pyramids served a FAR greater purpose than as the tombs for pharaohs lie that is claimed today.
The idea that a Bronze Age civilization like the Egyptians could’ve built the pyramids is laughable at best. Bronze is an extremely soft metal. And yet they managed to quarry millions of tons of quartz and granite with it?! That is physically impossible. Its like saying you cut down a forest of red woods with a plastic knife.
 
Open debate. Please keep it respectful.

While we share many core values, where do Protestants get it wrong?

1. wrong Bible. Luther doesnt get to eliminate 1500 years of sacred scripture.

2. They devalue the Eucharist.

3. Mary is revered, not worshiped, for Catholics. Prots, in reaction, disrespect her.

4. Purgatory is biblical.

5. Baptism occurs to eliminate original sin. No need to wait until you are “saved.”

6. Sola scriptura and sola fide are nonsense.

7. Apostolic succession.

8. Catholicism is more conservative, and a better, more unchangeable barrier against liberalism.

Original thoughts only. No links accepted.
The Catholic Church is a ruling body where priests are referred to as fathers. The Original Sin Christening is not Baptism because a baby has no idea why they are being Baptized. A true Baptism is for the Remission of Sin and following Jesus Christ's commandment to be Baptized. Furthermore, we are commanded to learn the scriptures (not have priests try to dumb it down for us).
 
The Catholic Church is a ruling body where priests are referred to as fathers. The Original Sin Christening is not Baptism because a baby has no idea why they are being Baptized. A true Baptism is for the Remission of Sin and following Jesus Christ's commandment to be Baptized. Furthermore, we are commanded to learn the scriptures (not have priests try to dumb it down for us).
Well, that’s just a difference in teachings. The Catholic Church teaches Bapttism is for original sin. Confession and Penance is for remission of sins.

As far as learning Scripture, too many Protestants have their own interpretations. I prefer it to be explained by people that actually are qualified to understand the history behind it. But then you may prefer the prosperity gospel and one that glorifies capitalism over love, humility and love of thy neighbor. in other words, confirmation bias.
 
Last edited:
After reading all this stuff. How is this one for you? Matthew 15:14. Let them alone: they be blind leaders of the blind. And if the blind lead the blind. both shall fall into the ditch.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dr. Curmudgeon
Well, that’s just a difference in teachings. The Catholic Church teaches Bapttism is for original sin. Confession and Penance is for remission of sins.

As far as learning Scripture, too many Protestants have their own interpretations. I prefer it to be explained by people that actually are qualified to understand the history behind it. But then you may prefer the prosperity gospel and one that glorifies capitalism over love, humility and love of thy neighbor. in other words, confirmation bias.
We don't need a Pope to be the head of a church. That is strictly Jesus' job in a Judeo-Christian Church.
 
  • Like
Reactions: martycat1
Historically, the Bishop of Rome was at least regarded as the “First among Equals.” The Eastern Orthodox church actually reasserted this doctrine recently as a part of their ongoing ecumenical process with the RCC.

But the papacy really gained its preeminence as a result of most of the eastern churches being overtaken by other groups during Late Antiquity. In the third century, Jerusalem was conquered by the Sassanids. And the Muslims eventually conquered all of Christiandom outside of Western and Central Europe. The West became isolated and Rome was now the biggest center of Christianity that wasn’t oppressed by another group. This is arguably when the pope saw its role shift from “First among Equals” to the supreme authority in the Church.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Dr. Curmudgeon
Without looking, what are the seven sacraments of the Catholic Church. I only got six.
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT