ADVERTISEMENT

Florida Baseball 2025

Even the great ones have an off season eventually.
Grit teeth and move on past it if this season end up as a stinker....
I won't worry about Sully unless he can't turn it around next season.
(same for softball if they struggle)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Nicktheslick
Even the great ones have an off season eventually.
Grit teeth and move on past it if this season end up as a stinker....
I won't worry about Sully unless he can't turn it around next season.
(same for softball if they struggle)
Completely agree. O'Sullivan has proven himself to be one of the greats of college baseball. He can't control the injuries, but needs to figure out why some of his players aren't developing like they should. He consistently has a Top 10, usually Top 5, recruiting class and yet this is the second year in a row we're struggling to finish the season above .500.
 
  • Like
Reactions: instaGATOR
Completely agree. O'Sullivan has proven himself to be one of the greats of college baseball. He can't control the injuries, but needs to figure out why some of his players aren't developing like they should. He consistently has a Top 10, usually Top 5, recruiting class and yet this is the second year in a row we're struggling to finish the season above .500.
ehhh, if we're being honest Sully hasn't been much more than a Calipari of baseball with all the talent he's had.. I appreciate how many trips to Omaha we've had, but to have only won one time with the loaded rosters he's had.. It's time for people to start having some real conversations and be tough about how "great" is he actually.
 
Sully’s got a lifetime gig as far as I’m concerned but this is 3 years running where his pitching stinks and he recruits anyone he wants. So I do hope he’s taking a hard look at our approach. Seems like we never throw anything off speed for strikes. Everything breaking is off the plate. So we get a lot of strikeouts but we end up in a bunch of hitters counts and they can just sit on fastballs and destroy them.

And hitting we swing a lot early in the count. So we run into some good pitches but when we dont hit them we end up behind in the count.

Generally we are ALWAYS behind in the count, pitching or hitting, and that’s bad baseball.

Sully bitches about it all the time but it’s like dude, you’re the head coach.
 
  • Like
Reactions: gatordad3
ehhh, if we're being honest Sully hasn't been much more than a Calipari of baseball with all the talent he's had.. I appreciate how many trips to Omaha we've had, but to have only won one time with the loaded rosters he's had.. It's time for people to start having some real conversations and be tough about how "great" is he actually.
Well, if we're being FACTUAL, Florida's baseball program has been ranked as one of the Top 5 in the nation for a long, long time. And the reason for that is Kevin O'Sullivan. He's gotten us to the CWS 9 times since he came to Gainesville in 2008. We'd only been 5 times in our entire history before that. 6 regular season SEC titles under Sully as well.
D1 Baseball ranks UF as the 4th best overall baseball program as of March 25, 2025. In 2024 they had us as the #3 program, with rankings in the Top 5 going back to 2015. That's the "honest" truth.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: instaGATOR
yea, it's certainly not fair especially at this point to critique Sully AT ALL.. getting fortunate to make the CWS last year covered up and made people forget the year was a DISASTER, and this one is maybe the worst one we've seen or it's shaping up to be.
 
Sully’s got a lifetime gig as far as I’m concerned but this is 3 years running where his pitching stinks and he recruits anyone he wants. So I do hope he’s taking a hard look at our approach. Seems like we never throw anything off speed for strikes. Everything breaking is off the plate. So we get a lot of strikeouts but we end up in a bunch of hitters counts and they can just sit on fastballs and destroy them.

And hitting we swing a lot early in the count. So we run into some good pitches but when we dont hit them we end up behind in the count.

Generally we are ALWAYS behind in the count, pitching or hitting, and that’s bad baseball.

Sully bitches about it all the time but it’s like dude, you’re the head coach.
Look I appreciate the hell out of what Sully has done for our baseball program long term, but all these things you're saying are right.. and they're constant and never get changed, that's not a good sign of good baseball management.. So we have to simply out talent everyone, cool as long as he keeps getting that talent.. again, VERY john calipari'ish.. the baseball version.
 
These are the batting averages from the 12 in conference games played so far.....
28 Heyman, Luke .386
10 Shelton, Colby .333
6 Boser, Bobby .280
16 Yost, Hayden .250
11 Lawson, Brendan .243
29 Donay, Brody .219
5 Cyr, Blake .216
2 Evans, Ty .182
30 Wilson, Ashton .167
13 Stripling, Landon .152
1 Nadeau, Justin .132

You can point at other batting stats if you want but they don't get much better. And here are the team numbers for and against...
Totals .244
Opponents .311

These are the pitching ERAs from the 12 in conference games played so far.....
9 McNeillie, Luke 4.38
47 King, Aidan 5.40
12 Peterson, Liam 7.90
20 Clemente, Jake 9.00
99 Montsdeoca, Carson 9.00
34 Philpott, Alex 9.53
23 Barlow, Billy 10.64
22 Barberi, Jackson 13.50
44 Ong, Felix 13.50
33 Biemiller, McCall 15.75
21 McDonald, Caden 18.00
8 Rodriguez, Christian 21.00
17 Gomberg, Jacob 40.50
26 Janssens, Niko 54.00
37 Jenkins, Matthew 99.00

Then ask yourself if you were coach, how would build a pitching rotation with these kind of numbers???
And here are the team ERA numbers for and against...
Totals 9.63
Opponents 4.03
 
  • Like
Reactions: bradleygator
ehhh, if we're being honest Sully hasn't been much more than a Calipari of baseball with all the talent he's had.. I appreciate how many trips to Omaha we've had, but to have only won one time with the loaded rosters he's had.. It's time for people to start having some real conversations and be tough about how "great" is he actually.
Say what???
 
Sully has been a great baseball coach, but he has a lot of personal baggage only a few of us know about. I'm not sure it is his fault, but it is what it is. Those who know, know. But to be truthful it has nothing to do with the current state of the baseball team. I do not watch Gator baseball until the the basketball season is over. I watched us beat the Nulls tonight. Sully is pissed about his pitchers and rightly so. These guys can't throw strikes. It's a matter of proven statistical science that a good pitcher vs a good batter, the pitcher who throws strikes wins 66% of the time against even the best hitters as long as they don't walk batters and get into full blown jams. The Gator pitchers can't get out of their own way in this regard, I don't care what kind of heat you got.
 
Last edited:
4 wins in the SEC. Need 8 more. Won’t be easy but they’re out there.
Yep - We have to start somewhere and a sweep against a very weak Missouri team is as good a place as any. We go to Starkville next weekend and right now they're only 4-10 in the SEC with another game tomorrow. But after that we have Arkansas, South Carolina, Texas & Alabama. Going 8-7 down the stretch ain't gonna be easy. But at least now we have a chance to make a run to get back in the hunt for an NCAA bid. Pitching was much better this weekend than it has been in a good while.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bradleygator
Barberi just shredding Stetson, gives up 2 two out walks leads to 4 runs. Everything away away away. Throw strikes for Pete’s sake.
 
I think another sweep is just asking too much given how they've looked this year in SEC play, but it's the right time to finally get it together if you're gonna do it...
 
  • Like
Reactions: bradleygator
I think another sweep is just asking too much given how they've looked this year in SEC play, but it's the right time to finally get it together if you're gonna do it...
Totally agree. We've got 15 games left to win 8 or more. Miss. State is having about the same kind of year we have. After Miss St. we host #2 Arkansas, then play @ South Carolina (2-13 in the SEC), then @ #1 Texas, then finish hosting #15 Alabama. Winning 2 of 3 from Miss. St. & South Carolina are almosts musts at this point, sweeping both or either would help us a lot. Digging out of the hole we dug to get to at least 12 wins is going to be really hard, even playing better.
 
Here is why Florida is still in the hunt for an NCAA bid.

As of today, the Gators are #26 in RPI and #6 in SOS. What hurts is that we're only 3-12 in Quad 1 games. We've got a bunch of them coming up and we just need conference wins, but if we end up a bubble team, we'll more than likely have an edge becuase of our tough schedule and RPI.
 
Do you guys think, as of today we are capable of doing something similar to last years team? I got to see last years team a lot more than this one so far
 
Do you guys think, as of today we are capable of doing something similar to last years team? I got to see last years team a lot more than this one so far
I think we can win just about any series we play if we pitch up to our talent. Thats what happened last year is guys started pitching and the rotation and bullpen kind of got sorted out and sully figured out who should be pitching where (remember we were trying to start Neely for about half the year and then he was absolutely lights out at the back of the bullpen).

Will that happen? I’m not overly optimistic. Peterson was supposed to be a top SEC starter and top 10 draft type of guy and he hasn’t been close to that. Menendez and Coppola looked like very solid weekend starters and they’re both hurt.

We have talent in the bullpen but everybody’s been inconsistent. It looks like Sully may want Barlow to close and I don’t love that. It seems like by Sunday, our pitching is pretty exhausted.

Our lineup is worse than last year, as you would expect losing Cags. And Shelton, who is a great hitter, has been more of a line drive hitter, which I think is more natural for him but combined with cags being gone that’s probably 50 home runs we’re missing. Was hopeful Donay might hit 25-30, but he’s looked overmatched in the SEC.

I’d say our lineup is about a C+ SEC lineup.

So I think we could go on a run but we just need to take it game by game and hopefully win the series we can and not get swept. The Vandy sweep was a killer.

If we can get into a regional, obviously nobody better than Sully at getting the team to Omaha.

I’d say we’re about 2/1 against to make a regional.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 46885
I made it almost 2 innings, yea I don't know how y'all watch that.. It's the same exact thing every year, every game. Every player in the lineup swings at balls 6 feet from the plate and watches strikes down the dick. It's calipari the baseball version, there's literally no way he hasn't gotten a hitting coach or at least pretended they have a different approach by now. Its the exact same problems I watched since 2012, but we don't have 5 Mike Zunino's to cover it up.
 
I made it almost 2 innings, yea I don't know how y'all watch that.. It's the same exact thing every year, every game. Every player in the lineup swings at balls 6 feet from the plate and watches strikes down the dick. It's calipari the baseball version, there's literally no way he hasn't gotten a hitting coach or at least pretended they have a different approach by now. Its the exact same problems I watched since 2012, but we don't have 5 Mike Zunino's to cover it up.
What do you think now? 13-3 run rule win. It's a complete game, not 2 innings. Gators have now won 4 SEC games ina row and looked great tonight. Enjoy the ride and quit complaining.
 
Last edited:
Yeah everyone i tut tutted blew up. Good start for Peterson. He got pretty unlucky early in the game. Giving up 4 infield hits for 2 runs.

Donay and Heyman went crazy. Bullpen solid. That’s how you do it. Love to see one more tomorrow.
 
What do you think now? 13-3 run rule win. It's a comp;lete game, not 2 innings. Gators have now won 4 SEC games ina row and looked great tonight. Enjoy the ride and quit complaining.
I still think exactly the same thing, because this is the problem.. when all this talent finally starts doing what they should it actually makes Sully look worse.. think about it. When you watch the baseball team every year, it looks like no one manages or coaches the team AT ALL. The things I originally said and have been saying for years will still show back up and be their downfall.. Unless the hitters get more disciplined and drive the ball where it's pitched, which they did the rest of the game btw.. the same issues exist. This team should have the fire power to do what they did, but whether it's them all striking out or the pitching being awful it all comes back to who is running the show. Brody Donay alone has so much power he hits routine fly balls that leave the yard like Aaron Judge
 
I still think exactly the same thing, because this is the problem.. when all this talent finally starts doing what they should it actually makes Sully look worse.. think about it. When you watch the baseball team every year, it looks like no one manages or coaches the team AT ALL. The things I originally said and have been saying for years will still show back up and be their downfall.. Unless the hitters get more disciplined and drive the ball where it's pitched, which they did the rest of the game btw.. the same issues exist. This team should have the fire power to do what they did, but whether it's them all striking out or the pitching being awful it all comes back to who is running the show. Brody Donay alone has so much power he hits routine fly balls that leave the yard like Aaron Judge
Except for you it seems that virtually everybody, including college baseball experts and his fellow coaches, say O'Sullivan is one of the best and most consistent coaches in college baseball. 18 years and 8 SEC titles and 9 College World Series appearances, 1 national title. There are other programs with equal or better talent year in and year out - LSU, Arkansas, Vanderbilt, Texas, Texas A&M, just to name a few. And yet compare their 18 year performace to Florida's and it will not equal Sully's. You just like to complain and it's pretty baseless.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Nicktheslick
God forbid if anyone has any criticism of Sullys consistent and repetitive problems, if you think Florida shouldn't have more than one Ring with our rosters over the years then we are becoming Mike Martin FSU
 
I still think exactly the same thing, because this is the problem.. when all this talent finally starts doing what they should it actually makes Sully look worse.. think about it. When you watch the baseball team every year, it looks like no one manages or coaches the team AT ALL. The things I originally said and have been saying for years will still show back up and be their downfall.. Unless the hitters get more disciplined and drive the ball where it's pitched, which they did the rest of the game btw.. the same issues exist. This team should have the fire power to do what they did, but whether it's them all striking out or the pitching being awful it all comes back to who is running the show. Brody Donay alone has so much power he hits routine fly balls that leave the yard like Aaron Judge
We'll see if they can turn it around against Arkansas, S Carolina, Texas and Bama. I hope I'm wrong but I doubt it.
 
our pitchers are so frustrating, like the creative way he just got the bases juiced for MSU there with no outs.. then he throws so much gas he just pitches himself out of the jam entirely impressively. They're so unpredictable
 
our pitchers are so frustrating, like the creative way he just got the bases juiced for MSU there with no outs.. then he throws so much gas he just pitches himself out of the jam entirely impressively. They're so unpredictable
The SEC is a grind. No easy teams, no easy games. Throwing a freshman pitcher on Saturday at Miss. State where they have crods of 12-15,000, is something he's never seen. King came into the game 4-1 with a 2.68 ERA. Baseball is THE sport in Starkville. Passionate fans and they always have great players. They've lost a ton of 1-run games this year and beating them is always tough.
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT